An exception to a universal generalization is a counterexample that refutes the generalization. All you need is one. Generic statements cannot, however, be similarly refuted. 'Nuns don't smoke cigars' is a generic statement. If you turn up a nun who smokes cigars I won't take you to have refuted the generic statement. I'll dismiss the exception as an 'outlier.'
Memo to self: develop this line of thinking and then apply it to 'hot button' issues such as race. Is Candace Owens representative of black females or is she an 'outlier'? And to which generic statements is she an outlier? You won't touch this question, will you? Not with an eleven-foot pole, which is the pole you use to touch questions you won't touch with a ten-foot pole.
See my aptly appellated entry, Generic Statements, for more on generic statements.
Recent Comments